Pandaward assessment report

acme-shop

asmt_0001_20261028T204903Z · COMPLETE · profile local-passive · revision 5e17870a6457947826be30aa316c027412ea5492 · 2026-10-28T20:49:03Z to 2026-10-28T20:49:03Z

Automated technical security assessment. Not a certification, attestation, legal opinion or independently signed penetration test, and not a guarantee that no vulnerabilities exist. Only the controls listed as PASS were decisively checked, and only for the stated scope, method and point in time.

Summary

Confirmed, open20

Suspected, needs review11

Decisive coverage40%21 of 52 applicable controls

Not decided31controls, never read as secure

Cross-domain edges150 verified · 5 failed · 10 open

Coverage counts decisively tested controls (PASS/FAIL) over applicable controls. It is not a percentage of vulnerabilities found. BLOCKED, UNSUPPORTED, SUSPECTED, INCONCLUSIVE, ERROR and STALE never count as secure.

Confirmed observations (20)

PW-0022 · pull_request_target checks out untrusted PR code

critical CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: .github/workflows/ci.yml:8
Control: N-003 pull_request_target workflows do not check out untrusted PR code
CWE: CWE-829
Why: pull_request_target runs with repository secrets and a write token; checking out the PR head lets any fork author run code with them.
Fix: Use pull_request for building untrusted code, or split into an unprivileged build and a privileged workflow_run that only consumes artifacts.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-cicd completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_4a7f9c2c4be3bcdb via builtin-cicd

PW-0004 · Hardcoded GitHub token

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: app.py:8
Control: E-001 No high-confidence secret patterns in repository files
CWE: CWE-798
Why: A value matching the GitHub token format is stored in the repository. The value is masked in all Pandaward output.
Fix: Revoke and rotate the credential at the provider first, then remove it from the code and git history; load it from a secret manager or environment at runtime.
Retest: Re-run `pandaward scan`; also verify with the provider that the old credential is revoked.
Evidence: ev_4fc7c8c69e031156 via builtin-secrets

PW-0005 · Hardcoded Stripe live secret key

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: src/server.js:2
Control: E-001 No high-confidence secret patterns in repository files
CWE: CWE-798
Why: A value matching the Stripe live secret key format is stored in the repository. The value is masked in all Pandaward output.
Fix: Revoke and rotate the credential at the provider first, then remove it from the code and git history; load it from a secret manager or environment at runtime.
Retest: Re-run `pandaward scan`; also verify with the provider that the old credential is revoked.
Evidence: ev_17b39394ce37dd0a via builtin-secrets

PW-0006 · Credential or environment file tracked in git

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: .env
Control: E-002 Environment and credential files are not tracked in git
CWE: CWE-538
Why: This file type usually holds credentials and is committed to git. Pandaward did not read its content.
Fix: Rotate any credentials it contains, `git rm --cached` it, add it to .gitignore, and purge it from history if the repository is shared.
Retest: Re-run `pandaward scan`; the file must no longer be tracked.
Evidence: ev_2b3c5175a0b4065c via builtin-secrets

PW-0008 · TLS certificate verification disabled

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: app.py:5
Control: E-003 TLS certificate verification is not disabled in code
CWE: CWE-295
Why: Certificate verification is turned off, so any network attacker can impersonate the server.
Fix: Remove the override; trust a specific CA bundle if a private CA is needed.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_e8d11c07675dc9ab via builtin-code

PW-0009 · Shell command execution

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: app.py:6
Control: D-002 No shell command construction through a shell interpreter
CWE: CWE-78
Why: Command runs through a shell interpreter.
Fix: Use subprocess.run([...], shell=False) with an argument list.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_94913aefcc6346ee via builtin-code

PW-0010 · Dynamic code evaluation

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: app.py:7
Control: D-001 No dynamic code evaluation (eval/new Function/exec of strings)
CWE: CWE-95
Why: eval/exec evaluates strings as Python code.
Fix: Use ast.literal_eval for literals or explicit parsing; never eval input.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_a9c4d034c668acc8 via builtin-code

PW-0014 · Dynamic code evaluation

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: src/server.js:8
Control: D-001 No dynamic code evaluation (eval/new Function/exec of strings)
CWE: CWE-95
Why: Strings are evaluated as code. If any part of the string can be influenced by a user, this is code injection.
Fix: Replace eval/new Function with explicit parsing or a lookup table; never evaluate strings.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_7eb1da32ab0560fe via builtin-code

PW-0017 · CORS allows any origin with credentials

high STRONGLY_SUPPORTED OPEN

Location: src/server.js:4
Control: H-002 CORS is not configured as wildcard together with credentials
CWE: CWE-942
Why: Any origin (or a reflected origin) is allowed together with credentials, so other sites can make authenticated reads.
Fix: Use an explicit allowlist of trusted origins when credentials are enabled.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_8f75c59732ca936d via builtin-code

PW-0021 · Untrusted event data interpolated into a run script

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: .github/workflows/ci.yml:11
Control: N-002 No untrusted event data interpolated into run: scripts
CWE: CWE-78
Why: Attacker-controlled text (titles, bodies, branch names) is expanded into the shell script before it runs, allowing command injection in CI.
Fix: Pass the value through an environment variable (env: TITLE: ${{ ... }}) and reference "$TITLE" in the script.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-cicd completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_d4c0b7d0aaff8778 via builtin-cicd

PW-0026 · Public storage or database exposure

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: infra/main.tf:1
Control: J-004 IaC does not expose public storage or world-open admin ports
CWE: CWE-284
Why: The resource is configured for public access.
Fix: Keep storage and databases private; serve public files through a CDN with explicit, read-only policy.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-infra completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_4f9bf0d255e934f1 via builtin-infra

PW-0027 · Administrative or database port open to the internet

high STRONGLY_SUPPORTED OPEN

Location: infra/main.tf:6
Control: J-004 IaC does not expose public storage or world-open admin ports
CWE: CWE-284
Why: A security group/firewall rule allows 0.0.0.0/0 near an SSH, RDP or database port.
Fix: Restrict the source to a VPN/bastion range or use a managed access proxy.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-infra completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_822dc4e9c892428a via builtin-infra

PW-0029 · Android app is debuggable

high CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml:1
Control: K-001 Android manifest: not debuggable, no backup, no cleartext traffic
CWE: CWE-489
Why: Manifest sets android:debuggable="true". Static observation; runtime impact depends on build variant.
Fix: Set android:debuggable to false for release builds (use build-type manifest placeholders).
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-mobile completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_cdde459f87b81902 via builtin-mobile

PW-0020 · GitHub Action not pinned to a commit SHA

medium CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: .github/workflows/ci.yml:9
Control: N-001 Third-party GitHub Actions pinned to a full commit SHA
CWE: CWE-829
Why: someone/deploy-action@main uses a mutable reference; whoever controls that tag/branch can change the code that runs with this workflow's secrets.
Fix: Pin to the full 40-character commit SHA of a reviewed release and keep the version in a trailing comment; let Dependabot/Renovate update it.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-cicd completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_b013c649d18f6fc3 via builtin-cicd

PW-0023 · Workflow does not declare GITHUB_TOKEN permissions

medium CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: .github/workflows/ci.yml:1
Control: N-004 Workflow GITHUB_TOKEN permissions declared explicitly
CWE: CWE-250
Why: Without a permissions block the token gets the repository default, which may be read-write for everything.
Fix: Add `permissions: contents: read` at the top level and grant extra scopes per job only where needed.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-cicd completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_bc44fe7969b08ac8 via builtin-cicd

PW-0025 · Container runs as root

medium CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: Dockerfile:1
Control: J-001 Container images do not run as root
CWE: CWE-250
Why: The final image stage has no non-root USER, so a compromise of the process is root inside the container.
Fix: Create an unprivileged user and add `USER <uid>` in the final stage.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-infra completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_2dd232b952152e08 via builtin-infra

PW-0028 · Package manifest without lockfile

medium CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: package.json:1
Control: I-001 Every package manifest has a committed lockfile
CWE: CWE-829
Why: Without a committed lockfile every install can resolve different transitive versions, including a newly published malicious one.
Fix: Commit the lockfile and install with the frozen/ci mode (npm ci, pip install --require-hashes, go mod verify).
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-supply completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_e081c5b1020366d9 via builtin-supply

PW-0019 · GitHub Action not pinned to a commit SHA

low CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: .github/workflows/ci.yml:6
Control: N-001 Third-party GitHub Actions pinned to a full commit SHA
CWE: CWE-829
Why: actions/checkout@v4 uses a mutable reference; whoever controls that tag/branch can change the code that runs with this workflow's secrets.
Fix: Pin to the full 40-character commit SHA of a reviewed release and keep the version in a trailing comment; let Dependabot/Renovate update it.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-cicd completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_4611c27259ceb153 via builtin-cicd

PW-0024 · Base image not pinned

low CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: Dockerfile:1
Control: J-002 Container base images pinned (no latest or missing tag)
CWE: CWE-829
Why: The base image uses latest or no tag, so builds are not reproducible and can silently pick up a changed image.
Fix: Pin a specific version tag, ideally with @sha256 digest, and update it deliberately.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-infra completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_98bb7a66c22d7481 via builtin-infra

PW-0030 · Android backup enabled

low CONFIRMED OPEN

Location: android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml:1
Control: K-001 Android manifest: not debuggable, no backup, no cleartext traffic
CWE: CWE-530
Why: Manifest sets android:allowBackup="true". Static observation; runtime impact depends on build variant.
Fix: Set android:allowBackup to false for release builds (use build-type manifest placeholders).
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-mobile completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_1c22ef1d4a6f0958 via builtin-mobile

Suspected signals (11)

Heuristic or reviewer-proposed hypotheses. They are not confirmed vulnerabilities until verified.

PW-0007 · Unsafe deserialization API

high HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: app.py:4
Control: D-004 No unsafe deserialization APIs on untrusted data
CWE: CWE-502
Why: Deserializing untrusted data with this API can execute code.
Fix: Use JSON or yaml.safe_load; never unpickle data from outside the trust boundary.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_45edd1ca1b90d972 via builtin-code

PW-0011 · Model output may reach code or shell execution

high HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: app.py:7
Control: P-001 Model output is not executed as code or shell
CWE: CWE-94
Why: An execution sink appears on the same line as model output. Prompt injection could turn into code execution.
Fix: Treat model output as untrusted data: parse into a typed structure, validate against an allowlist, require human approval for side effects.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_f6f8776e80a54556 via builtin-code

PW-0013 · SQL built with string concatenation

high HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:6
Control: D-003 No SQL statements built by string concatenation or interpolation
CWE: CWE-89
Why: Query text is concatenated with values; if a value is user controlled this is SQL injection.
Fix: Use parameterized queries / prepared statements or the ORM query builder.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_9163cd2dde765988 via builtin-code

PW-0015 · Shell command built from a string

high HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:8
Control: D-002 No shell command construction through a shell interpreter
CWE: CWE-78
Why: child_process.exec or shell:true runs the command through a shell; interpolated values allow command injection.
Fix: Use execFile/spawn with an argument array and shell:false; validate arguments against an allowlist.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_18bcf670b9fe88b6 via builtin-code

PW-0018 · Webhook handler without visible signature verification

high HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:7
Control: G-001 Webhook handlers verify a signature before acting on the payload
CWE: CWE-345
Why: No signature/HMAC verification was found in the file that defines this webhook route. Verification may live in middleware; confirm manually.
Fix: Verify the provider signature over the raw request body with a constant-time compare before parsing or acting; reject replays by timestamp/event ID.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_fdf34989adaac10f via builtin-code

PW-0001 · Route not declared in the OpenAPI contract

medium HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:8
Control: A-003 Declared API contract (OpenAPI) matches discovered routes
Why: GET /admin/run is implemented but not documented; undocumented endpoints often miss contract and authorization tests (shadow API).
Fix: Document the endpoint in the OpenAPI contract with its security requirements, or remove it if unused.
Retest: Re-run `pandaward scan`; the route must appear in the contract comparison.
Evidence: ev_efa0768a93861314 via builtin-inventory

PW-0002 · Route not declared in the OpenAPI contract

medium HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:6
Control: A-003 Declared API contract (OpenAPI) matches discovered routes
Why: GET /api/invoices/:id is implemented but not documented; undocumented endpoints often miss contract and authorization tests (shadow API).
Fix: Document the endpoint in the OpenAPI contract with its security requirements, or remove it if unused.
Retest: Re-run `pandaward scan`; the route must appear in the contract comparison.
Evidence: ev_47d3f7f67228fdd6 via builtin-inventory

PW-0003 · Route not declared in the OpenAPI contract

medium HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:7
Control: A-003 Declared API contract (OpenAPI) matches discovered routes
Why: POST /webhooks/stripe is implemented but not documented; undocumented endpoints often miss contract and authorization tests (shadow API).
Fix: Document the endpoint in the OpenAPI contract with its security requirements, or remove it if unused.
Retest: Re-run `pandaward scan`; the route must appear in the contract comparison.
Evidence: ev_2de440fb1038ae7e via builtin-inventory

PW-0012 · jwt.decode used (no signature check)

medium HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:5
Control: B-001 JWT verification is not disabled and does not accept the 'none' algorithm
CWE: CWE-347
Why: jsonwebtoken's decode() does not verify the signature; trusting its output for authorization is unsafe.
Fix: Use jwt.verify(token, key, { algorithms: [...] }) for anything security relevant.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_ba4887d7098ce9c5 via builtin-code

PW-0016 · Raw HTML sink

medium HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: src/server.js:9
Control: H-001 No raw HTML injection sinks (innerHTML, dangerouslySetInnerHTML, v-html, |safe)
CWE: CWE-79
Why: Content is inserted as raw HTML. If it can contain user data this is cross-site scripting.
Fix: Render as text, or sanitize with a maintained sanitizer (DOMPurify) right at the sink.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-code completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_3492a3599d7b8d70 via builtin-code

PW-0031 · Exported Android component without permission

medium HYPOTHESIS OPEN

Location: android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml:3
Control: K-002 Android exported components protected by permission
CWE: CWE-926
Why: Any installed app can invoke this receiver. Confirm it validates callers and input.
Fix: Set android:exported="false" unless required, or protect it with a signature-level permission.
Retest: Apply the fix, then run `pandaward retest`; the finding becomes REMEDIATED only when builtin-mobile completes and no longer observes it.
Evidence: ev_385c21dd4cc2e520 via builtin-mobile

Coverage by domain

Domain	PASS	FAIL	SUSPECTED	BLOCKED	UNSUPPORTED	INCONCLUSIVE	NOT_APPLICABLE
A Asset inventory, architecture and threat model	1	0	1	1	0	1	0
B Authentication, sessions and identity	1	0	1	1	1	0	0
C Authorization, roles and tenant isolation	0	0	0	3	0	0	0
D Input, output, injection and data flow	0	2	2	2	0	0	0
E Secrets, cryptography, privacy and storage	1	3	0	1	0	0	0
F Business logic, integrity and financial workflows	0	0	0	1	1	0	0
G API contracts, integrations and messaging	0	0	1	0	1	0	0
H Web frontend, browser and client-side controls	0	0	2	1	0	0	0
I Dependencies, SBOM and software supply chain	1	1	0	1	0	0	1
J Cloud, infrastructure, network and IaC	0	3	0	1	0	0	1
K Android application security	1	1	1	1	0	0	1
L iOS application security	0	0	0	0	0	0	4
M Dynamic application/API security testing	0	0	0	1	0	0	0
N CI/CD, source control and release security	0	4	0	0	0	0	0
O Observability, detection and recovery	1	0	0	1	0	0	0
P AI/LLM, agents, prompts and MCP	0	0	1	0	1	0	1
Q Availability, concurrency and abuse resistance	0	0	0	1	1	0	0
R Reporting, governance and remediation assurance	1	0	0	0	0	0	1

Cross-domain edges

Edge	Scenario	Status	Reason	Provenance
AB1 Discovered login endpoints -> session tests	New auth route missing token/session coverage	BLOCKED	not decided: A-002=INCONCLUSIVE, B-003=UNSUPPORTED, B-004=BLOCKED	`route:POST:/api/login@src/server.js`
AC1 Asset owners -> access policies	Orphan routes lack authorization checks	BLOCKED	not decided: C-002=BLOCKED, C-003=BLOCKED	`route:POST:/api/login@src/server.js, route:GET:/api/invoices/:id@src/server.js, route:POST:/webhooks/stripe@src/server.js, route:GET:/admin/run@src/server.js`
AD1 Input entrypoints -> sinks	Ingress path crosses a parsing or command boundary	FAIL	failed controls: D-001, D-002	`control:D-001, control:D-002, control:D-003, control:D-004, file:src/server.js`
AE1 Asset classification -> secret scan	Secret material flows into config, workflow or IaC	FAIL	failed controls: E-001, E-002	`control:E-001, control:E-002`
AG1 Service inventory -> API coverage	Undocumented endpoints bypass contract tests	BLOCKED	not decided: G-002=UNSUPPORTED	`openapi.yaml, route:POST:/api/login@src/server.js, route:GET:/api/invoices/:id@src/server.js, route:POST:/webhooks/stripe@src/server.js, route:GET:/admin/run@src/server.js`
AJ1 Cloud-deployed asset -> exposure	Private API exposed by ingress or policy drift	FAIL	failed controls: J-001, J-004	`route:POST:/api/login@src/server.js, route:GET:/api/invoices/:id@src/server.js, route:POST:/webhooks/stripe@src/server.js, route:GET:/admin/run@src/server.js, Dockerfile, infra/main.tf`
BC1 Authenticated identity -> authorization	Valid user can access another tenant's object	BLOCKED	not decided: C-001=BLOCKED	`route:POST:/api/login@src/server.js, route:GET:/api/invoices/:id@src/server.js`
BK1 Mobile identity -> Android storage	Token copied to Android insecure storage	FAIL	failed controls: K-001	`android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml, src/server.js, route:POST:/api/login@src/server.js`
CG1 Object access -> API response	Mass assignment or property-level data access	BLOCKED	not decided: C-001=BLOCKED, G-002=UNSUPPORTED	`route:GET:/api/invoices/:id@src/server.js`
DG1 Webhook input -> API trust	Unsigned callback payload drives privileged state	SUSPECTED	suspected: G-001	`route:POST:/webhooks/stripe@src/server.js`
DH1 HTML output -> browser	Unescaped backend content reaches the DOM	SUSPECTED	suspected: H-001	`control:H-001`
DP1 Prompt content -> tools	Untrusted retrieved text triggers a tool action	BLOCKED	not decided: P-003=UNSUPPORTED	`app.py`
FG1 Payment state -> webhooks	Replay moves payment into an invalid terminal state	BLOCKED	not decided: F-001=BLOCKED	`src/server.js, route:POST:/webhooks/stripe@src/server.js`
FQ1 State machine -> race	Concurrent requests bypass idempotency	BLOCKED	not decided: F-002=UNSUPPORTED, Q-002=UNSUPPORTED	`src/server.js`
IN1 Action dependency -> CI integrity	Unpinned third-party action may change code	FAIL	failed controls: N-001	`.github/workflows/ci.yml`

Control ledger

Control	Title	Method	Status	Reason
A-001	Repository inventory walk completed without unreadable or skipped files	static	PASS	9 text files analyzed, none skipped
A-002	Externally reachable routes enumerated with file references	static	INCONCLUSIVE	4 HTTP routes, 0 GraphQL operations, 0 gRPC methods, 0 queue consumers and 0 cron jobs extracted heuristically with file and line (`pandaward routes`); completeness is not proven without a contract or runtime crawl
A-003	Declared API contract (OpenAPI) matches discovered routes	static	SUSPECTED	3 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
A-004	Asset owners, trust boundaries and abuse cases reviewed	manual	BLOCKED	manual-assisted review required (/pandaward:review); not decided by automation
B-001	JWT verification is not disabled and does not accept the 'none' algorithm	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
B-002	Session cookies are not explicitly configured without Secure/HttpOnly	static	PASS	check completed with no signal (code heuristics); PASS applies to this check only
B-003	Login, reset and MFA state machine tested with negative cases	runtime	UNSUPPORTED	runtime adapter for profile staging-active is not implemented in this release; use manual-assisted review
B-004	Session expiry and revocation enforced server-side	runtime	BLOCKED	needs an identity with revoked: true and authorization_checks in an approved scope manifest, then `pandaward test --profile staging-active`
C-001	Object-level authorization enforced on parameterized routes (BOLA)	runtime	BLOCKED	needs identities and authorization_checks in an approved scope manifest, then `pandaward test --profile staging-active`
C-002	Function-level authorization enforced on privileged routes	runtime	BLOCKED	needs identities and authorization_checks in an approved scope manifest, then `pandaward test --profile staging-active`
C-003	Authorization checks reviewed for every route handler	manual	BLOCKED	manual-assisted review required (/pandaward:review); not decided by automation
D-001	No dynamic code evaluation (eval/new Function/exec of strings)	static	FAIL	2 confirmed observation(s)
D-002	No shell command construction through a shell interpreter	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s), 1 suspected
D-003	No SQL statements built by string concatenation or interpolation	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
D-004	No unsafe deserialization APIs on untrusted data	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
D-005	Injection probes executed against approved target	runtime	BLOCKED	needs zap.active_scan: true in an approved scope manifest, ZAP installed and `pandaward test --profile staging-active`
D-006	Semgrep data-flow rules (SSRF, path traversal, template injection) and project rules report no findings	external	BLOCKED	semgrep is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
E-001	No high-confidence secret patterns in repository files	static	FAIL	2 confirmed observation(s)
E-002	Environment and credential files are not tracked in git	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
E-003	TLS certificate verification is not disabled in code	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
E-004	No weak hash or non-cryptographic random used for security values	static	PASS	check completed with no signal (code heuristics); PASS applies to this check only
E-005	Gitleaks reports no secrets	external	BLOCKED	gitleaks is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
F-001	Business invariants for money and entitlement flows documented and reviewed	manual	BLOCKED	manual-assisted review required (/pandaward:review); not decided by automation
F-002	Idempotency and double-processing tested with synthetic fixtures	runtime	UNSUPPORTED	runtime adapter for profile staging-active is not implemented in this release; use manual-assisted review
G-001	Webhook handlers verify a signature before acting on the payload	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
G-002	Runtime API authorization matches the declared contract	runtime	UNSUPPORTED	runtime adapter for profile staging-active is not implemented in this release; use manual-assisted review
H-001	No raw HTML injection sinks (innerHTML, dangerouslySetInnerHTML, v-html, \|safe)	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
H-002	CORS is not configured as wildcard together with credentials	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
H-003	Security response headers present on approved deployed target	runtime	BLOCKED	needs `pandaward test --profile production-observe` with an approved scope manifest
I-001	Every package manifest has a committed lockfile	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
I-002	Dependencies with install-time scripts are listed for review	static	PASS	check completed with no signal (lockfiles, install scripts, requirement pins, MCP configs); PASS applies to this check only
I-003	No known-vulnerable dependencies in an advisory database	external	BLOCKED	osv-scanner is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
I-004	Python requirements pinned to exact versions	static	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'python_reqs' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
J-001	Container images do not run as root	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
J-002	Container base images pinned (no latest or missing tag)	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
J-003	No privileged containers or host networking in compose/Kubernetes	static	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'orchestration' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
J-004	IaC does not expose public storage or world-open admin ports	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s), 1 suspected
J-005	Trivy reports no IaC misconfigurations	external	BLOCKED	trivy is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
K-001	Android manifest: not debuggable, no backup, no cleartext traffic	static	FAIL	2 confirmed observation(s)
K-002	Android exported components protected by permission	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
K-003	Android runtime storage and transport verified on emulator	runtime	BLOCKED	needs runtime.android_package, a running emulator with the debuggable test build, and `pandaward test --profile local-runtime`
K-004	Android app does not keep credentials in plain SharedPreferences or world-accessible storage	static	PASS	check completed with no signal (android manifest, iOS plist and entitlements, mobile storage checks); PASS applies to this check only
K-005	Built APK manifest: not debuggable, no backup or cleartext, no unprotected exported components	external	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'apk' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
L-001	iOS App Transport Security does not allow arbitrary loads	static	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'ios' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
L-002	iOS keychain and storage verified on simulator	runtime	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'ios' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
L-003	iOS entitlements do not allow debugging outside debug builds	static	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'ios' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
L-004	iOS credentials kept in the Keychain with a restrictive accessibility class, not in UserDefaults	static	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'ios' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
M-001	Passive DAST (ZAP baseline) against approved target	runtime	BLOCKED	needs `pandaward test --profile staging-active` with an approved scope manifest and ZAP installed
N-001	Third-party GitHub Actions pinned to a full commit SHA	static	FAIL	2 confirmed observation(s)
N-002	No untrusted event data interpolated into run: scripts	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
N-003	pull_request_target workflows do not check out untrusted PR code	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
N-004	Workflow GITHUB_TOKEN permissions declared explicitly	static	FAIL	1 confirmed observation(s)
O-001	Security events logged and alerted (privilege changes, auth failures)	manual	BLOCKED	manual-assisted review required (/pandaward:review); not decided by automation
O-002	Secrets and credentials not written to logs	static	PASS	check completed with no signal (code heuristics); PASS applies to this check only
P-001	Model output is not executed as code or shell	static	SUSPECTED	1 heuristic signal(s) need review; not confirmed
P-002	MCP server configs pinned and free of inline credentials	static	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'mcp_config' assets found in inventory (review this decision)
P-003	Prompt-injection and tool-authorization cases tested	runtime	UNSUPPORTED	runtime adapter for profile staging-active is not implemented in this release; use manual-assisted review
Q-001	Rate limiting applied to authentication and expensive routes	manual	BLOCKED	manual-assisted review required (/pandaward:review); not decided by automation
Q-002	Concurrency and duplicate-action tests on stateful flows	runtime	UNSUPPORTED	runtime adapter for profile staging-active is not implemented in this release; use manual-assisted review
R-001	All evidence artifacts of this assessment verify against recorded SHA-256	static	PASS	31 evidence artifacts verified against SHA-256
R-002	Imported third-party analyzer results (SARIF) report no findings	external	NOT_APPLICABLE	auto: no 'sarif' assets found in inventory (review this decision)

Tool runs

Adapter	Version	Result	Signals	Detail
builtin-cicd	0.2.1	OK	5	1 workflows
builtin-code	0.2.1	OK	12	code heuristics
builtin-infra	0.2.1	OK	4	dockerfile/compose/k8s/terraform checks
builtin-inventory	0.2.1	OK	3	15 assets
builtin-mobile	0.2.1	OK	3	android manifest, iOS plist and entitlements, mobile storage checks
builtin-secrets	0.2.1	OK	3	16 secret formats checked; 1 sensitive file names recorded without reading
builtin-supply	0.2.1	OK	1	lockfiles, install scripts, requirement pins, MCP configs
gitleaks		BLOCKED	0	gitleaks is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
osv-scanner		BLOCKED	0	osv-scanner is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
semgrep		BLOCKED	0	semgrep is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)
trivy		BLOCKED	0	trivy is not installed (optional; run `pandaward doctor`)

Evidence index

31 redacted artifacts under .pandaward/private/evidence/, named by SHA-256.

Evidence	SHA-256	Collector	Source
ev_17b39394ce37dd0a	`17b39394ce37dd0a0de700dbb903572efdc354be838155d54c2c8d0e2efeb0b8`	builtin-secrets	`src/server.js#L2-L2`
ev_18bcf670b9fe88b6	`18bcf670b9fe88b64d139efde10e65e0274fd3ea4a73c2a93e2c4a572da8695c`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L8-L8`
ev_1c22ef1d4a6f0958	`1c22ef1d4a6f09581363dd3d521b89f576fca9e2b7bb6e7726d2f7f3b454df37`	builtin-mobile	`android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml#L1-L1`
ev_2b3c5175a0b4065c	`2b3c5175a0b4065c3599ce12d8dba7960e6c5b9bd6c16c3947e367598bbbd094`	builtin-secrets	`.env`
ev_2dd232b952152e08	`2dd232b952152e08f1ef75802cc28bd5c6a074299101c0cb03b2cf1b68185a6a`	builtin-infra	`Dockerfile#L1-L1`
ev_2de440fb1038ae7e	`2de440fb1038ae7e66d537bbf6b430507479cf5d1ce6519a58c423374907823d`	builtin-inventory	`src/server.js#L7-L7`
ev_3492a3599d7b8d70	`3492a3599d7b8d7016a07bcb9ed0773f888387f2c95f9d77d8e6ca53c4012d5d`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L9-L9`
ev_385c21dd4cc2e520	`385c21dd4cc2e520f0876003cd58591eaffa08d917771aca8bace033edbe4a72`	builtin-mobile	`android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml#L3-L3`
ev_45edd1ca1b90d972	`45edd1ca1b90d972b8b85cde1a248bcffb06f92e712dda6b36da2a3d7fc9fce5`	builtin-code	`app.py#L4-L4`
ev_4611c27259ceb153	`4611c27259ceb1535e0118b38d6fcd0380e333979e1415875926554f10ca9f10`	builtin-cicd	`.github/workflows/ci.yml#L6-L6`
ev_47d3f7f67228fdd6	`47d3f7f67228fdd6afc263d85982473a7b4838a60bf30fa2fdbc3b75bf60a86e`	builtin-inventory	`src/server.js#L6-L6`
ev_4a7f9c2c4be3bcdb	`4a7f9c2c4be3bcdb8687f118ec4015e3782a9ea4a7080672b281f92d07d6fa0a`	builtin-cicd	`.github/workflows/ci.yml#L8-L8`
ev_4f9bf0d255e934f1	`4f9bf0d255e934f197e52ca274cb292eb831a90bd499a2021158cc82d14881ac`	builtin-infra	`infra/main.tf#L1-L1`
ev_4fc7c8c69e031156	`4fc7c8c69e031156263780edf79b4f52804e1991029f5388c4d6ab98516afcaa`	builtin-secrets	`app.py#L8-L8`
ev_7eb1da32ab0560fe	`7eb1da32ab0560fe2ee8962ada80f96dbe720e4c9aeedcadfd3dd40feef13daa`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L8-L8`
ev_822dc4e9c892428a	`822dc4e9c892428aea1fa57990ff08b0f58ac5f189179141e81ae2d071516875`	builtin-infra	`infra/main.tf#L6-L6`
ev_8f75c59732ca936d	`8f75c59732ca936db9fb6715c44a20e9772c50aceb3f8d022c970a5700bce04d`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L4-L4`
ev_9163cd2dde765988	`9163cd2dde7659880af78bc17e9b265ce83f9248557f2a54824be4725b7647a3`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L6-L6`
ev_94913aefcc6346ee	`94913aefcc6346ee4a0057bf92ee3bdaa7889ff39d20b3818bf17f30e656a4b7`	builtin-code	`app.py#L6-L6`
ev_98bb7a66c22d7481	`98bb7a66c22d7481eea003e7ec8b2dbabedd051499b73798d6e0f57e013ff363`	builtin-infra	`Dockerfile#L1-L1`
ev_a9c4d034c668acc8	`a9c4d034c668acc81cd7cdb434c4597d35e6d7568a4840db216326a061460f3f`	builtin-code	`app.py#L7-L7`
ev_b013c649d18f6fc3	`b013c649d18f6fc37f8cefa1ea850deb9289169e1cfec887694e8ca51d5acbe1`	builtin-cicd	`.github/workflows/ci.yml#L9-L9`
ev_ba4887d7098ce9c5	`ba4887d7098ce9c5f0d133ba772bbe0cf45b1ff2b3d2476df689e3571594bee8`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L5-L5`
ev_bc44fe7969b08ac8	`bc44fe7969b08ac86db054aafb4d26b89586d08b0546ef694b8cc58f309a1ff7`	builtin-cicd	`.github/workflows/ci.yml#L1-L1`
ev_cdde459f87b81902	`cdde459f87b819027a96c9f7a2836db82d3d87d999df46fa3fe668c4097e3dfc`	builtin-mobile	`android/app/src/main/AndroidManifest.xml#L1-L1`
ev_d4c0b7d0aaff8778	`d4c0b7d0aaff8778b011b8b9a3db6440e2d144f22060290a326be3462e364fda`	builtin-cicd	`.github/workflows/ci.yml#L11-L11`
ev_e081c5b1020366d9	`e081c5b1020366d9d14573e4fecfa24b1afacb3bc3f9b5a6472f6245d090d880`	builtin-supply	`package.json#L1-L1`
ev_e8d11c07675dc9ab	`e8d11c07675dc9abaa9d111a717bdc9914443d8969b9f52ab584a747cec0060c`	builtin-code	`app.py#L5-L5`
ev_efa0768a93861314	`efa0768a9386131425422ebad65848b31fefd3a4d9265fab15f93834bc2f61cc`	builtin-inventory	`src/server.js#L8-L8`
ev_f6f8776e80a54556	`f6f8776e80a545566da22965fa764a799f2401818a4b866cc32f2e26914b2a4a`	builtin-code	`app.py#L7-L7`
ev_fdf34989adaac10f	`fdf34989adaac10f800ab39fe8ed55cf4515004df04443de3800ab24a195cf02`	builtin-code	`src/server.js#L7-L7`

Generated 2026-10-28T20:49:03Z by pandaward 0.2.1.